Mechanical keyboards use individual switches; membrane keyboards use a rubber dome under the keys. Neither is universally faster, but the feel, sound, and travel can affect comfort and accuracy.
This page breaks the comparison into what each option measures, when it is the better choice, and what the difference means for your practice. The test above lets you try a representative format before you decide.
The short answer
Do not expect a new keyboard to raise your WPM by itself. Pick the board that feels comfortable for long sessions, then practise on it consistently. Accuracy and comfort beat switch marketing.
What each one measures
Mechanical switches offer more consistent feedback and are often easier to repair or customise. Membrane keyboards are usually quieter, lighter, and less expensive. Typing speed depends more on familiarity than on switch type.
The number on the screen is only useful if you know what it represents. A test that rewards burst speed and a test that rewards endurance can both be valid while pointing you toward different practice.
When Mechanical keyboard is the better choice
Choose mechanical if you want tactile feedback, customisation, and a keyboard you can maintain. Try a few switch types before buying.
Choose the format that matches the decision you are trying to make. A daily warm-up, a job application, and a long workplace simulation do not need the same test.
When Membrane keyboard is the better choice
Choose membrane if you want a quiet, low-cost keyboard for shared spaces or occasional use.
If you are unsure, run both formats on the same day and compare accuracy first. A large speed difference with a large accuracy difference usually means the faster result is not the more useful one.
How to use both in practice
A sensible routine uses both: mechanical keyboard for one kind of check and membrane keyboard for another. Keep the keyboard and time of day consistent so the comparison is fair. Review the trend over several weeks rather than reacting to a single result.
Frequently asked questions
Is mechanical keyboard better than membrane keyboard?+
Do not expect a new keyboard to raise your WPM by itself. Pick the board that feels comfortable for long sessions, then practise on it consistently. Accuracy and comfort beat switch marketing.
Which one should a beginner use?+
Start with the shorter, simpler format so you can build a clean baseline. Add the longer or more specialised format once your accuracy is stable.
Do the results transfer between formats?+
Partly. The underlying keyboard skill transfers, but the score does not. Always compare like with like and note the format alongside the number.
Can I use both in the same week?+
Yes. Many typists use a short test for daily feedback and a longer test once a week. The important thing is to keep the comparison consistent.
Keep practising
More practice: typing test hub · tests by duration · tests by purpose · language tests